Spider-Man: Brand New Day Fan Theories Ranked
Now that Spider-Man: Brand New Day is in theaters, all those wild fan theories about the film's true villain can finally be put to rest. For months people were dissecting everything from Sadie Sink's mysterious character reveal to how this movie might be setting up the Avengers: Doomsday storyline. Screen Rant ranked the fan theories by how accurate they actually turned out to be—turns out some fans were spot-on while others were way off base. It's the kind of retrospective that's fun if you're into the deep-dive speculation game, though honestly half the fun was the theorizing before we knew anything.
ComicsBuzz Take
With major MCU films now consistently leaking or getting theorized into the ground before release, it'll be interesting to see if studios eventually lean into the speculation rather than fight it—maybe even intentionally seeding false theories as red herrings.
💬 Fan Reactions
"Called the villain twist in March, feeling vindicated rn"
— u/MarvelCalled on Reddit